Fone Forum

3UK is to start limiting mobile broadband traffic from Monday, throttling P2P application and restricting video streaming on overloaded cells.

From Monday morning a congested cell will automatically limit peer-to-peer traffic and reduce video streaming to 400Kb/sec per customer, in an attempt to share out the available bandwidth between users.

The company is branding the steps an attempt to improve the "customer experience", and say they'll only be applied in congested areas.  Differential levels of service, with different tariffs, will come later.

The idea that everyone gets the same service is outmoded and customers should be at liberty to pay for faster connectivity or take a discount deal with more-limited speeds.  The technology to do that exists today, but 3 won't be deploying it initially: for now the emphasis is on throttling down those perceived as using an unfair proportion of the available bandwidth.

Bandwidth is a limited resource and 3 would much prefer to support 200 users on a cell with only a few hundred kilobits each, than 20 users downloading video files while the rest can't get at their email - though the 20 users concerned might not feel the same way.

More granular control over data rates is obviously going to be an important revenue source in the future. The flat rate (effectively) unlimited tariff is encouraging exactly the kind of price war that voice bundles were designed to defuse: it's in the operator's interest to make pricing too complicated to compare, but flat-rate data makes that difficult.

Chopping up the allowance by application, and allowing customers to pay for greater speeds and priority access, will make things much more complicated.  Those prepared to spend a few days working out the details will probably save money while the rest of us just pay more for the convenience of not having to think about it.

3 hasn't gone that far, at least not yet, but it's certainly the first step down that road.

See:-   TheRegister (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/11/12/3_traffic_shaping/).

Update:-


UK mobile operator 3 has insisted hardly anyone will be affected by the traffic shaping regime it will bring in on Monday.

3's plan is to introduce traffic shaping from Monday, but while the plan was to limit customers attached to congested cells to a single video stream as well as choking P2P applications, the operator has now decided that video streams will be left intact, and only P2P applications will be restricted.

The operator had sent us the following explanatory quote:

"In order to improve the service for the majority of our customers, we are actively managing the amount of bandwidth made available for peer-to-peer file sharing and limiting the number of streaming video sessions to one at a time per user at peak times."

Except that it has changed its mind about the video streams since then, so only P2P users on congested cells should feel the pain, as 3 limits their bandwidth to make space for everyone else.

3's reticence and back-pedalling is understandable.  The company is very wary of being the only mobile operator shaping traffic in this way, but the reality is that the rest of the operators - fixed and mobile - are going to have to follow suit.  If they aren't already.

Customers will have to get used to the idea of paying for the bandwidth they use: the majority of low-volume users cannot be expected to subsidise the few who have to have the latest American TV shows early.

But getting to the position of charging users for differing levels of service will require a lot of very small steps - some of them backwards.

See:-   here (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/11/13/3_traffic_shaping_again/).